Protein Shakes: Weight Loss Aid or Just Liquid Calories? by Sally Conroy

Picture Credit

Health and wellness significantly depend upon the choices people make. Often, in the
pursuit of health, people come across confusing options. It becomes necessary to look at each option more deeply to separate fact from fiction and make a wise choice.

In the circles of fitness enthusiasts and the quest for a fit physique, a protein shake is an option that often inspires debates and questions. Some people cannot imagine their fitness journey without the aid of protein shakes, while some insist that protein shakes are just extra liquid calories. This article will delve into the complex interplay between protein shakes, calories, and weight loss and explain the science behind it to enable informed decisions.

Protein Shakes and Weight Management

​Under normal circumstances, an adult human being requires 45 to 65 grams of protein a day. The requirement increases when a person consciously tries to build lean muscle mass and frequently exercises for longer durations.

Higher protein intake can aid in weight loss. Studies have shown that, as compared to other macronutrients, protein keeps a person full for longer. This effect is partly due to the release of GLP-1 and PYY, the fullness hormones. A higher intake of protein is associated with decreased appetite and a diminished desire to eat. Moreover, when combined with strength training, protein shakes can help build muscles. They may also increase metabolism temporarily. These effects and multiple studies support the claim that protein powders can aid weight management. Along with supporting weight loss, protein shakes also minimize short-term weight regain.

Calorie Consumption From Protein Shakes

Picture Credit

However, with protein shakes, there is an increased risk of excess calorie consumption, especially if a person does not have sufficient understanding or knowledge. Typically, all protein shakes have some carbohydrate content and varying amounts (and even types) of protein. Some protein shakes have a higher sugar and fat content. These differences between protein shakes and the way people consume them can affect the calorie intake.

People either purchase pre-made liquid shakes or use protein powders and other ingredients to make their own shakes. The problem with purchased liquid shakes (non-standard versions) is that it is difficult to figure out the ingredients and calculate the calorie content.  The pre-made store-bought versions do have ingredients and calorie content listed on the labels, but in a hurry, people often skip reading these. When preparing protein shakes at home, it is quite possible to forget to count the calories from the other added ingredients. All such factors can lead to higher-than-intended calorie consumption.
​
The Right Way to Use Protein Shakes

Picture Credit

While selecting protein powders or shakes, it is important to study the ingredients and calorie content. Ideally, the protein shake should have minimal amounts of added sugar and fat.

Avoid depending on protein shakes as the sole source of nutrition. Rather, for maximum benefits, it is better to incorporate protein shakes into a balanced but low-calorie diet. Additionally, it is vital to increase physical activity in conjunction with the consumption of protein shakes. Pay attention to the frequency of consumption as well as the portion size. It is advisable to follow recommended serving guidelines.

Conclusion

Whether a protein shake will act as a weight loss aid or just extra liquid calories depends on its composition as well as the manner of consumption. In general, protein shakes can prove beneficial for weight management. However, moderate consumption along with a balanced diet is desirable for maximum effectiveness. Careful scrutinization of the nutritional profile is necessary when purchasing protein shakes or powders. It is best to consult a doctor or dietician before starting any protein supplements.